Coburn Amendment Quashed
In a vote of 40-59, Sen. Tom Coburn’s (R-OK) Amendment No. 436 to immediately eliminate the Volumetric Ethanol Excise Tax Credit (VEETC) and the tariff on imported ethanol was quashed. Coburn’s proposal needed 60 votes to move forward but fell short by 20 votes. Shortly after the news hit, the ethanol industry began calling for “real reform.”
“The fight is not over until we achieve real reform for the ethanol industry, but this vote sends a signal that there is a right way and a wrong way to go about it,” said Growth Energy CEO Tom Buis. “For more than a year, Growth Energy has advocated for our Fueling Freedom plan, which would phase out the VEETC in a fiscally responsible way, while redirecting the funds toward ethanol infrastructure build out. Opening the fuels market to ethanol, through Flex Fuel pumps and Flex Fuel vehicles, would give consumers a choice at the pump and allow us to ultimately eliminate all government assistance.”
The industry applauded the Senators who voted to stop the amendment from moving forward. Renewable Fuels Association President and CEO Bob Dinneen said, “This vote demonstrates the lack of appetite for this kind of destructive policy and political gamesmanship. The Senate and the country need to focus on a comprehensive energy strategy that seeks to expand America’s ability to renewably meet its fuel needs.”
Yesterday the ethanol industry joined together in support of another proposal introduced by Senators Thune and Klobuchar. This proposal also eliminates VEETC in its current form but replaces it with a variable tax incentive tied to the price of oil, which hit more than $120 a barrel today, a five week high. This proposal would also allocate funds to improve ethanol infrastructure and supports tax policies for emerging ethanol technologies.
“This vote is a major victory for the biofuels industry and American consumers and a setback for those clinging to our status-quo dependence on oil,” added Brian Jennings, executive vice president of the American Coalition for Ethanol. “It proves political stunts aimed at ethanol won’t be tolerated in the U.S. Senate. Now we can focus on continuing our work with the White House and both chambers of Congress to support meaningful and responsible legislation to reform ethanol policy.”



7 Comments »
If Senate repeals ethanol subsidies, what happens at the gas pump? – Christian Science Monitor | Real Digital News
[...] subsidies fails pass voteReutersSeattle Post Intelligencer -Atlanta Journal Constitution -Domestic Fuelall 391 headlines [...]
Senate Rejects Coburn Bid to Eliminate Ethanol Tax Break, Tariff – BusinessWeek | Inholland
[...] Senate sidetracks move to repeal ethanol creditAlbany Times UnionAtlanta Journal Constitution -Domestic Fuel -Wisconsin Agriculturistall 441 news [...]
Greg Guenther
Tom Coburns’ attempt to eliminate the VEETC failed and rightfully so. The ethanol industry is willing to give up VEETC but only if the oil industry is willing to give up the literally billions of tax breaks and hidden incentives that they receive from the Federal Government.
The whole idea of eliminating tax breaks for the energy sector is almost a joke anyway. The industry needs a certain amount of income and if they don’t get it from tax breaks from the government they will get it at the pump. Either way consumers are going to pay, it is just a question of where and how much. For my part, pricing at the pump is the most transparent.
Ethanol Future Could be Headed to Senate Showdown - Domestic Fuel
[...] the defeat Tuesday in the Senate of an amendment by Sen. Tom Coburn (R-OK) to immediately eliminate the Volumetric Ethanol Excise Tax Credit [...]
More Ethanol Dialogue Needed - Domestic Fuel
[...] the budget while still ensuring the ethanol industry can move forward. Yet while many believe the Senate’s defeat of Sen. Coburn’s ethanol amendment opens the door for dialogue, others believe today’s action does little to move the [...]
More Senate Ethanol Votes Today - Domestic Fuel
[...] two days after an amendment by Sen. Tom Coburn (R-OK) was defeated, the Senate is expected to vote on the same amendment, the effort this time spearheaded by Senator [...]
Millons Spent on Lobbying for VEETC Reform - Domestic Fuel
[...] Tax Credit (VEETC) were voted on by the Senate. While the first vote was in favor of ethanol (it defeated the Coburn amendment), the industry took a hit when Sen. Dianne Feinstein’s (D-CA) bill was passed, essentially [...]
Comments RSS feed — TrackBack URI
Leave a Comment